This Floridian's Annuity Proceeds May Not Be Creditor Protected
Annuities are exempt in Florida, and so are annuity proceeds. A client consulted with me today regarding assets which include a bank account, in his own name, which account contains $20,000 of annuity proceeds. There is no money in this bank account other than these annuity proceeds. Florida courts have protected annuity proceeds after they have been deposited in the debtor's financial account as long as the money is traceable to an annuity. The annuity proceeds in this debtor's bank account represent a final payment of an annuity purchased by his mother in New York for the debtor's benefit. The debtor/son was the sole annuity beneficiary. The money is exempt, right? I thought so until I re-read the annuity statute. Now, I'm not so sure the money is protected from the son's creditors.
Florida's annuity statute, Section 222.14, exempts "the proceeds of annuity contracts issued to citizens or residents of the state, upon whatever form...." My client is a Florida resident and the only annuity beneficiary, but the annuity was not issued to my client. The annuity was issued to his mother who was a resident of New York. I don't think the annuity qualifies for exemption under the statute because it was not issued to a resident of Florida, and therefore, I do not believe the annuity proceeds are exempt from the client's creditors.
However, there is a 1996 court decision the Jacksonville Division of the Middle District of Florida wherein the bankruptcy judge disagreed with my interpretation of the statute. This judge found that the statute requires only that the "proceeds" of the annuity contract be issued to Florida residents. In re Allen, 203 B.R. 786.
